The concert secretary's diary is the part of working men's club life most people forget about, and it's the part that tells you the most. Saturday night was always booked months in advance. A top turn at half-eight, a second spot at ten, bingo wedged in the gap so the committee could count the room and the singer could have a pint. The diary lived behind the bar in a ring-bound book with a brewery logo on the cover, and the entries were written in pencil because acts cancel.

I keep coming back to that diary because it's the one artefact that captures what the clubs actually were. Not the snug, not the snooker table, not the Anaglypta-papered concert room with the stage at one end and the framed photograph of the 1962 outing to Blackpool on the back wall. The diary. Someone in the committee, usually a man in his sixties with a job at the post office, would phone agents on a Tuesday afternoon and book three months out. He'd negotiate the fee, write the act name, the time, and a small shorthand only he understood: V/G for very good, N/A for not again. The whole booking economy of British grassroots entertainment ran through these pencil entries.

The Club and Institute Union was founded in 1862 by the Reverend Henry Solly, who wanted somewhere working men could go that wasn't a public house. It grew into the largest network of member-owned social institutions the country has ever had. By 1939 there were 2,863 affiliated clubs. The heyday came later, the 1960s and 70s, when the CIU represented around 4,500 venues and the concert circuit was thick enough that an unknown comic could play three different rooms in one weekend without leaving West Yorkshire. Today the affiliated number is 1,175.

That collapse has a date. The smoking ban in 2007 was the cliff-edge, but the slide began earlier, with the end of heavy industry and the spread of cheap home entertainment. A steward in Halifax told the Telegraph and Argus in 2010 that Saturday-night takings had fallen 35 per cent in a year and the concert audience was down from over a hundred to forty or fifty. By 2023 the BBC was visiting Cleethorpes Working Men's Club where the bar manager said takings had dropped between sixty and seventy per cent in twelve months. The committee was debating whether to drop the word men from the name to widen the membership pool. They were not the first.

What haunts me about the clubs isn't the architecture, which was usually unlovely. It's the rota. A working men's club ran on the assumption that adult life contained recurring fixed events: the Wednesday meeting, the Friday domino night, the Saturday concert, the Sunday dinner, the annual outing to the seaside, the Christmas children's party where Father Christmas was the same retired joiner every year. The rota assumed continuity, that the same people would turn up at the same time and that the calendar of the year had a public, shared shape.

The shape's gone. Saturday night isn't a fixed event any more. People don't book three months in advance for a turn they've never heard of, on the recommendation of a committee man who spent forty years phoning agents. The Federation brewery at Dunston was sold to Scottish and Newcastle in 2004 for sixteen million pounds. The convalescent homes at Saltburn and Grange-over-Sands closed long before that. What remains is a network of buildings, mostly in the north and the midlands, with diaries that still get filled in pencil but with fewer entries every year.

I don't think the working men's club is coming back. The conditions that produced it, an industrial workforce with regular hours and a strong sense that leisure was something you did with other people in the same room, have disappeared. But the institution it replaced was the public house, and the public house has lasted seven hundred years. It's possible the diary will be the bit that survives, in archive form, somewhere a sociologist can read it, a record of a society that had a shared calendar and didn't think this was remarkable.

Sources: